R5 Restaurant Review: The Sterling Inn

A Brilliant, Creative Debut

Since its opening last summer, New Rochelle’s Sterling Inn has demonstrated the makings of a culinary jewel


- Advertisement -

During dinner at the sterling inn, I couldn’t help thinking of a book I’d recently read, Wife of the Chef, by Courtney Febbroriello. In it, Febbroriello writes of her front-of-the-house management duties in the restaurant she owns with her husband: “Being on the floor is like wearing a mask. People think that I am the gracious hostess of the year, but I’m not. I’m just a person like everyone else, working my ass off to make a living.” At our table, being graciously welcomed by Rachel Smith, restaurant co-owner and wife of Chef Sterling Smith, I wonder whether her feelings are similar. Is she smiling because she has to? Well, Rachel, smile because you should. Your restaurant is terrific.       


Considering Chef Smith’s pedigree—Culinary Institute of America, Virginia’s The Inn at Little Washington, Manhattan’s Aureole and Lespinasse—that’s not surprising. Now, with his own place, he says he is “ready to introduce my work to the Westchester community.” And boy, are we ready to receive it. He views the restaurant as a “creative palette” for his abilities and, in dish after dish, that creativity proves masterful.


The first inkling of his creativity comes with the amuse-bouche, a wine-steamed mussel atop piquant herbed black-eyed peas. Inkling becomes certainty with an appetizer of grilled scallops, its ham-inflected cushion of grits an artful ode to the chef’s Southern roots. And certainty becomes revelation with unctuous pork-belly cubes sparked by a miso glaze and caramelized shallots that will make you swoon. This is a chef in command of his talents, sure of his vision, so my disappointment with two other appetizers was pronounced. Chalk it up to new-kitchen foibles: an asparagus-sunchoke risotto exuding vanilla, and a truffled macaroni-and-cheese overly truffle-oiled and devoid of cheddar.

- Partner Content -


But we’re back on masterful ground with the questionably titled but certifiably delectable modern lobster borscht. Presented, as all these dishes are, in gleaming white oversized plates, this entrée approaches the conceptual. The coral sheen of lobster meat emerges from a pool of scarlet beet broth, and poised on the bowl’s rim, a white ceramic spoon cradles lucid pearls of Gewürztraminer gelée mounded like albino caviar. The gelée, we are instructed, is to be stirred into the liquid; the pearls bob for a moment, then vanish, absorbed. I don’t taste the wine, but the broth’s vegetal depth enhances the lobster’s sweetness. Smith has conceived a sensory triumph befitting its $32 cost.


Similarily expensive is the rack of lamb, rosy and abundant, with its pillowy batons of curry fries. The gravy-like sauce is nondescript, but its cabbage timbale harboring lamb shoulder confit—nonpareil! A perfectly pan-roasted black bass fillet is overpowered by a coriander crust, but its spaghetti-squash ragoût sings with grace notes of ginger and smoked tomato. This is complex, inspired cooking; innovation without gimmick, creativity honed by technique. Even Smith’s roasted chicken transforms the simple to the sublime: a succulent, meaty bird as far from Purdue as New Rochelle is from the Loire, the place I experienced a revelatory barnyard bird to which this one was comparable.


- Advertisement -

Complexity and inspiration extend to dessert, too. Those beets make an encore appearance in a mousse atop a buttery shortbread pastry, the sweetness tempered by citrus custard. Cappuccino infuses a fine crème brûlée, but I would have reduced the apple quartet offering to a trio—its Normandy cider gelée is more water than cider—though its apple-butter ice cream is delirious with flavor. Smith bows to convention with a molten chocolate cake, but his riff soars with wine-poached berries and a cadenza of piña colada sorbet.


So go enjoy Sterling Inn’s well-spaced tables, exposed brick, and fancy chandeliers. Sip wine from the reasonably priced, eclectic list. Appreciate the efficient service. Try brunch, which I intend to do soon, especially with items like smoked-cod-and-ratatouille omelets on the menu. And when the wife of the chef comes over, tell her she’s right to be smiling.



1279 North Ave., New Rochelle

(914) 636-2400



Tue. to Sun. from 5 pm

Brunch, Sun.11 am-5 pm



Appetizers: $9-$13

Entrees: $22-$32

Desserts: $8-$12

Brunch: $9-$15

Our CEOs & Business Leaders Golf Outing is August 5!

Our Best of Westchester Party is July 24!

Our Westchester Home Design Awards event is June 26!

Our Wine & Food Festival returns June 4-9!

Our Wunderkinds event takes place on May 23!

Our Best of Business Ballot is open through May 15!

Our Healthcare Heroes Awards event takes place on May 9!

Our Westchester Home Builders Awards take place on April 4!

Our Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Forum is March 14!

Unveiled: A Boutique Bridal Brunch is February 25!

Holiday flash sale ... subscribe and save 50%

Limited time offer. New subscribers only.