The Past is Preserved in the Renovation of a 200-Year-Old Farmhouse Renovation

Venture into a different world of nature and design with this revamped getaway.

A year before the Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence, a man named Joseph Wheadon built a modest, one-room house in New Milford, Connecticut. Wheadon cut the lumber by hand and scavenged foundation stones from the surrounding property. After his premature death, a Greek Revival wing was built, followed by other less-distinctive additions.

More than 235 years after Wheadon first wielded his ax, a Greenwich woman discovered the property while searching for a weekend retreat. By this time, the house was dated and neglected, with systems that had outlived their usefulness. “It was my duty to the community to maintain and uphold the architectural history of the house,” says the homeowner, a former student of historic preservation, now earning a doctorate in environmental policy. “However, on the backside of the house, I wanted to bring nature in and to connect the house to its surroundings.”

Related: Should You Really Modernize a Historic Home?

- Advertisement -

Houzz at a Glance

Who lives here: The home is a getaway for a local family of five

Location: New Milford, Connecticut

Size: 2,700 square feet; 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms

That’s interesting: The old foundation stones were used to build a labyrinth behind the house.

- Partner Content -

Blansfield Builders, Inc., original photo on Houzz


Working with Mark Goodwin of Beinfield Architecture, and Jim Blansfield of Blansfield Builders, the owner remodeled and expanded the house, opening the interior spaces to each other and the view.

The new column-lined entryway across from the garage pays homage to the 19th-century Greek Revival facade in front. The wing to the right was newly built, and the whole house was covered in standing-seam metal roofing, which is both easy to maintain and environmentally responsible — a consideration that drove much of the project.

“You venture into a different world when you venture inside,” observes Goodwin, who heeded the owner’s request to reduce every element to its simplest components.

- Advertisement -

The living-dining area is dominated by an original fireplace, now covered in reclaimed wood that’s been treated to a charcoal gray finish. “We tried to reuse as much of the wood as we could,” says Goodwin, who left some of the hand-hewn beams exposed and used one to create a sublimely understated mantel.

While the home feels like a radical departure from its Revolutionary past, the owner doesn’t see the two as incompatible. “If you look at the interiors, they’re contemporary in terms of being minimal,” she says. “But actually, those are the same materials that would have been used by the original builders. Instead of making it a relic of the past, we revived it and gave it a whole new identity.”

Related: Bring Your Traditional Home Up to Date With Contemporary Furniture

The living room sectional was custom crafted from Northern white pine, while the Andrianna Shamaris coffee table was fashioned from a tree stump. The engineered-wood floors (Castle Combe’s Worcester pattern) are made from oak, textured and treated to look like ancient reclaimed wood.


Blansfield Builders, Inc., original photo on Houzz


The neutral decor defers to the view. The garden room is visible through the doorway at rear.


Before Photo, original photo on Houzz


When the owner bought the house, the kitchen had barely been updated since the 1950s and still sported its vintage metal cabinets.


Blansfield Builders, Inc., original photo on Houzz


AFTER: “The owner wanted the house to be as simple as it could be,” says Goodwin, who conjured a space as refined as a Donald Judd sculpture. The owner didn’t want any upper cabinets cluttering the room, so Goodwin provided the most minimal of shelving. Vermont marble covers the island and counters — part of an effort to use only local materials.

The cabinets are treated with a high-gloss painted finish. The owner commissioned the rustic-simple table and picked out the hanging lights — once again opting for something as understated as possible.


Blansfield Builders, Inc., original photo on Houzz


The contractor tried to preserve the original master wing, but it was too fragile and had to be rebuilt. The bed now backs up to a wall covered with reclaimed wood from the old house.

The window wall offers views of 350-year-old maples, where the owner has observed falcons and owls roosting. “You feel like you’re in nature, but you’re not interrupting it,” she says.


Before Photo, original photo on Houzz


When the owner bought the house, the interiors were woefully dated, as evidenced by this pink-and-aqua bathroom — the only one on the main floor.


Blansfield Builders, Inc., original photo on Houzz


AFTER: A new master bath was added behind the wood wall in the bedroom. (These are the same transom windows visible over the bed.) The vanity features old barn wood, while the mirror above was drilled to accommodate both the faucets and the wall sconces — a task that took a couple of tries to master.

Related: Bathroom Mirrors to Add Some Shine to Your Design

Although the property is not large, it’s surrounded on three sides by a 220-acre agricultural preserve, so its perimeter seems boundless.

To keep the remodel environmentally responsible, the team reused everything they could from the old house and recycled the rest. They used cellulose insulation in the walls and ceiling, water-based adhesives, formaldehyde-free materials, low- or no-VOC paints, and an efficient-energy recovery ventilator.


Blansfield Builders, Inc., original photo on Houzz


The rear of the house isn’t visible to the public, so the owner felt more comfortable updating it with walls of glass. The yoga studio, at left, was added to form a U that embraces the central terrace.

The new garden room sits atop a former patio. While digging up the concrete slab, the construction team uncovered an old tombstone lying face-down in the dirt. It was the gravestone of the original owner, Joseph Wheadon, who died shortly after the house was completed.

While his remains were not found, the tombstone was kept in the spot where it was discovered — now preserved in an illuminated glass case and secured behind doors in the garden room.

Our Westchester Home Design Awards event is June 26!

Our Wine & Food Festival returns June 4-9!

Our Wunderkinds event takes place on May 23!

Our Best of Business Ballot is open through May 15!

Our Healthcare Heroes Awards event takes place on May 9!

Our Westchester Home Builders Awards take place on April 4!

Our Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Forum is March 14!

Unveiled: A Boutique Bridal Brunch is February 25!

Our Best of Westchester Elimination Ballot is open through March 6!

Holiday flash sale ... subscribe and save 50%

Limited time offer. New subscribers only.