8 Westchester Bakeries You Have to Try for Valentine’s Day

Head to these dessert maestros to guarantee some cupid lovin’.

Adobe Stock/  ltummy

Craving something sweet after dinner? Head to these dessert maestros to guarantee a little bit of cupid lovin’ before you adjourn for the evening.

Whether you’re celebrating Valentine’s Day with your sweetheart or treating yourself, these lovable holiday-themed desserts will make you wonder why they aren’t available year-round.

Cake Pops

Baked By Susan

379 S Riverside Ave, Croton on Hudson; 914.862.0874

We dare you to take more than one bite of this decadent dessert. Baked By Susan also makes the cutest gift for the kids (or kids at heart) in your life.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Baked by Susan (@bakedbysusan)

- Advertisement -

Sugar Cookies

Beascakes Bakery

575 Main St, Armonk; 914.273.3612

Nothing says “spreading love” quite like an expertly decorated, almost too-pretty-to-eat sugar cookie. But trust us, that feeling won’t last too long, and pretty soon all that’s let will be crumbs and glitter remnants.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Beascakes Bakery (@beascakesbakery)

Festive Brigadeiros

Boleria Brazilian Bakery

362 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck; 914.630.0100

- Partner Content -

For a sultry sweet that will make a lasting impression, the Brazilian brigadeiro should be your go-to. Made with a base of condensed milk and sold in a variety of flavors, our favorite is dark chocolate. Looking to make a bigger splash? The bakery is also filling chocolate shells with passionfruit, dulce de leche, and chocolate mousse.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Boleria Brazilian Bakery (@boleriany)

Whoopie Pies

By The Way Bakery

574 Warburton Ave, Hastings-On-Hudson; 914.478.0555

This dairy-free and gluten-free haven has a plethora of treats to offer this holiday, from cake truffles to heart-shaped sugar cookies. The headliner that has us hyped for the 14th is the whoopie pie, a moist cake with chocolate goodness in each bite and dressed in pink for the occasion.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by By the Way Bakery (@bythewaybakery)

- Advertisement -

Sweetheart Treat Box

Flour Power

4668 Boston Post Rd, Pelham; 914.222.0704

Near, far, wherever they are, these ultimate treat boxes could make anyone feel the love. Available in the bakery and for delivery, the assortment of a chocolate-covered brownie heart, a love letter rice krispie, chocolate-covered Oreo lips, and two chocolate-covered pretzel rods beats any stale supermarket sampler by a mile. Plus how adorable is it?

Marry Me Cherry Pie

Noble Pies

22 Purdy Ave, Rye; 914.305.3174

While not inherently Valentine’s Day, this pie (as the name suggests) could cause a spur-of-the-moment proposal.  Is there anything more romantic?


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Noble Pies (@noblepies)

Anything and everything

The Snackery Bake Shop

64 Purchase St, Rye; 914.481.1636

There is no lack of lovable sweets at The Snackery. From love cakes to little love monster treats, you’ll forget all about Valentine’s Day and feel more like a kid in a candy store at this bakery. Don’t forget to buy something for you—self love is important, wink wink.

Conversation Hearts Cake


380 Main St #1821, Armonk; 914.273.4777

Tell ‘em how you really feel this Valentine’s Day with a custom message on this Instagram-worthy cake. Throwing a Galentine’s Day instead? The bakery is also making man crush cakes (ours is Harry Styles, no judgement).


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Sugar Hi – NY Bakery (@sugarhi_ny)

Bonus: DeCicco & Sons

Don’t write off this supermarket’s bakery for Valentine’s Day. Filled with scrumptious homemade goods, no shopping trip is complete without a dozen of these thick-layered chocolate-covered strawberries.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by DeCicco & Sons (@deciccos)

Related: The Official Valentine’s Day Dining Guide for Westchester County