Type to search

How, When, and Where to Order Super Bowl Chicken Wings


The most popular wing spots in Westchester prepare literally tons of wings for Super Bowl Sunday, so put your orders in now.

It just wouldn’t be right to watch the big game without an order of wings. But if you want your Super Bowl party wings to come from your favorite restaurant, you probably need to plan ahead. Here are the details on ordering from some of the most popular wing spots in Westchester.


519 Central Park Ave, Scarsdale; 914.472.9706

Flavors: mild, hot, extra hot, Chernobyl, barbecue, bourbon honey barbecue, datil pepper, dry rub, garlic parm, teriyaki, scampi, plain
Prices: 5 wings, $10.75; 10 wings, $21.50; 15 wings, $32.25

Pickup/order details: Cash only; carry-out and dine-in

Courtesy Candlelight Inn


1769 Central Park Ave, Yonkers; 914.346.8820

This place has “wings” in the name, need we say more? They’re prepared double-fried or boneless.

Flavors: soy garlic, bbq, sweet & spicy, buffalo, hot pepper soy
Prices: 6 wings, $8.95; 10 wings, $13.95; 20 wings, $24.95
Pickup/order details: carry-out, dine-in

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Cravwings (@cravwing)

Lazy Boy Saloon

154 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains; 914.761.0272

Flavors: Buffalo, tequila citrus, honey barbecue, barbecue mesquite sesame, Jack honey, garlic Parmesan, teriyaki, Caribbean jerk, sweet bourbon Buffalo, habanero, honey chipotle
Prices: 10 wings, $13; 20 wings, $25; 30 wings, $37; half tray, $55; full tray, $110
Pick up/Order Details: carry-out, delivery, and dine-in
Bonus: Lazy Boy Saloon now offers cauliflower wings in buffalo sauce and tequila citrus.

Maggie Spillane’s Ale House

571 Gramatan Ave, Mount Vernon; 914.699.8900

Flavors: mild, spicy, teriyaki, bbq, sweet chili, garlic and herb, jerk, chipotle, honey mustard
Price: 10 wings, $12.99; 20 wings, $23.99; 30 wings, $32.99
Pickup/order details: carry-out, delivery, and dine-in; no half-time buffet or raffles/prizes

New York Firehouse Grille

63 Welcher Ave, Peekskill; 914.788.0808

Flavors: Their buffalo wings run from “False Alarm,” to “Four Alarm” to “Waiver Wings” (you will have to sign a waiver; we’ve done it), and they offer a variety of dry rubs and dozens of other sauces from which to choose. To list just a few from both the “heat” and “no heat” lists: barbecue, honey barbecue, barbecue ranch, PB&J, pizza, Buffalo, Volcano, Plain Jane, Guadalupe. Check out the website to see the full list of the more than 50 flavors on offer.  Super Bowl party packages also offer mozzarella sticks, burger or pulled pork sliders, pig skins, penne vodka, baby back ribs, and sampler platters, plus three- and six-foot sandwiches.
Prices: $45 for half-tray (serves 6-10); $80 for full tray (serves 10-14); additional snacks/packages available
Pick up/Order Details: Carry-out, delivery, and dine-in

Courtesy NY Firehouse Grille


320 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck; 914.341.1655

Flavors: Tailgate wings are available in Agave Glazed, Bama White BBQ, and Nashville Hot
Prices: 25 wings, $39.35; 50 wings, $79.95; 75 wings, $109.95; 100 wings, $129.95
Pickup/order details: Offering carry-out, delivery, and dine-in

Courtesy Smokehouse Tailgate Grill

Rooster’s Wings & Brew

1 Baker St, Mohegan Lake; 914. 743.1797

The wings at a place names “Rooster’s” had better be good, and these don’t disappoint. With more than 30 different sauce selections and plenty of sides and accompaniments, plus a contactless pick-up, you’d have to be chicken not to put in an order.

Flavors: Traditional, Southern-fried, boneless, and tenders available in combination with 30+ sauces and dry rubs
Prices: Traditional – 12 for $12.95 (3 sauces); boneless – 10 for $9.90 (1 sauce); Southern-fried – 10 for $12.95 (1 sauce); tenders – 6 for $11.95 (1 sauce)
Pickup/order details: Contactless window, curbside pickup, dine-in available; pre-order by February 1

Sam’s of Gedney Way

52 Gedney Way, White Plains; 914.940.0978

Cooking up a variety of gameday trays, Sam’s makes wings that are a touchdown no matter how you toss them.

Flavors: classic buffalo, maple barbecue, honey soy
Prices: 18 wings, $30
Pickup/order details: carry-out, dine-in


2136 Boston Post Rd, Larchmont; 914.833.3317

At this no-frills, friendly, neighborhood pub, the wings, ribs, and burgers are the big draw, but dessert is a standout, too, with the signature Rice Krispy treat pie (O.M.G.) a meal-ending must.

Flavors: Classic Buffalo
Prices: 8 wings, $9; 15 wings, $15
Pickup/order details: carry-out, dine-in, or heated beer garden dining

Stay up-to-date with our free email newsletter

Keep a pulse on local food, art, and entertainment content when you join our Westchester Magazine Newsletter.

No thank you