“Oh my God,” murmurs a customer who’s wandered off Palmer Avenue into The Snackery Bakeshop in Larchmont. And who can blame her? On the counter, artfully arranged in tin tubs, wicker baskets, and on old-timey glass cake stands, is a collection of swoon-worthy sweet and savory treats.
Homemade strawberry pop-tarts glisten with sprinkle-dappled icing; chocolate cupcakes have a cheery “hello” piped on top. Plump croissants — some plain, some boasting everything-bagel seeds — emit a tantalizingly buttery aroma. Fingers of spongy carrot cake with cream-cheese filling are arranged in alluring rows. From the hot pockets filled with spinach and ricotta to the perfectly browned churro muffins and hundred-layer donuts, every creation tempts and beckons.
Owner Sara Leand wouldn’t have it any other way. “I have a vision of being everybody’s new happy place, to evoke some memory of childhood,” she explains. A painted picket fence on the windows and a green doormat are meant to remind customers of a home, while an antique stove imparts a cozy feel. There’s even a viewing window through which you can watch the bakers’ clever creations being frosted and decorated, plus a party room at back (kids’ parties will start in 2019).
Leand, a self-taught baker, didn’t always intend to turn pro, though crafting delectable nibbles has long been her passion. In college she operated a cookie business, Sara Snacker, but after graduation, she hung up her apron for show biz. She spent years in Los Angeles working as a movie-studio executive and talent agent, then moved to New York and opened a production company.
Marriage and pregnancy changed her focus. “I wasn’t sure I wanted to keep running back to LA, so I started baking again,” she explains. She founded the Sara Snacker Cookie Company, selling to places such as Citarella and DeCicco & Sons. This fall, as the youngest of her kids headed off to school, the timing seemed right to open a bakery. The Snackery opened just days before Thanksgiving.
Its name aside, the shop has full-sized, exquisitely decorated cakes. All cakes have three layers and many can be filled with candy or sprinkles. While a fair number sport beautiful, pastel buttercream flowers or drizzled chocolate and salty pretzels, it’s the Hairy Cake — vanilla, red velvet, and Devil’s food layers and enough stringy frosting to resemble a Koosh ball or Cousin Itt — that’s the true standout.
Another fan favorite is The Snackery’s custom, easy-slice cookie cake, crafted into the initial or number of your choice. One thing you won’t find on the cakes is a lot of fondant. “We don’t do a unicorn or a lion jumping out of a fire. We wanted to go back to the old-school ways,” Leand explains.
The bakery is now taking holiday orders: Among the options are an eggnog cake, made with local Ronnybrook eggnog; the Giant Christmas Tree Cookie Cake, and roll cakes decorated with snowmen and Santas. The Snackery also features vegan treats (chocolate chip cookies and apple pie turnovers) and gluten-free offerings, including chocolate-chip loaves and skinny muffins made with oat flour, almond butter, dark chocolate, and apple sauce.
All the sweets got you thirsty? Never fear: A complete coffee-and-tea bar features products from Malongo, an upscale French line.
The Snackery Bakeshop
1985 Palmer Ave
Curious for more insight into everything from weddings and local business happenings to golf and hearty Westchester eating? Surf through all of our daily blogs.