Type to search

Where to Indulge Your Peanut Butter Cravings in Westchester

Photo courtesy of Smallcakes

It’s National Peanut Butter and Jelly Lover’s Day, so stop by one (or all!) of these Westchester spots to satisfy your peanut butter craving and celebrate properly.

Don’t go nuts looking for the perfect peanut butter treat…or burger (sounds weird, we know, but read on). There are a bunch of great spots spread all throughout Westchester, so it’s pretty easy to get your peanut butter fix on any given day, and it would be pretty nutty not to.

Duck Donuts

805 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck; 914.825.9722

The Peanut Butter Paradise donut from Duck Donuts tastes exactly how it sounds. The peanut butter icing and chocolate drizzle are simple yet delicious. If you’re craving a pop of color for spring, the new seasonal Berry Box assortment features a peanut butter icing donut with a pastel pink strawberry drizzle.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Duck Donuts (@duckdonuts)


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Duck Donuts (@duckdonuts)

Flour and Sun

19 Washington Ave, Pleasantville; 914.495.3232

If you’re looking for something vegan, Flour and Sun bakery has a cupcake made of vegan chocolate cake, peanut butter frosting, and a drizzle of peanut butter. The bakery also has a traditional peanut butter cupcake made of chocolate devil’s food cake, peanut butter buttercream, peanut butter cups, and a chocolate drizzle.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Flour & Sun Bakery (@flourandsun)

The Kneaded Bread

181 N Main St, Port Chester; 914.937.9489

The 2017 Best of Westchester peanut butter cookie is baked daily at the Kneaded Bread and awaiting peanut butter lovers. Cookies are ready by 10:30 a.m. and are baked continuously throughout the day, making them the perfect peanut butter pick-me-up.

Photo courtesy of The Kneaded Bread


Various Locations

Stock up your pantry with the Westchester-based and woman-owned Noomi peanut butter for National PB&J Day and beyond. Noomi is made from naturally sweet, organic, dry-roasted peanuts from North Carolina, organic Deglet Noor dates, nutrient-rich grapeseed oil, peanut oil, and Atlantic Sea salt. Find it at The Farmer’s Grind, Pound Ridge Organics, and Hudson Milk Co. More retailers can be found here, and you can look forward to Noomi being back in farmers’ markets in May.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Noomi® (@noomibrand)


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Noomi® (@noomibrand)


749 Central Park Ave, Scarsdale; 914.713.3971

Smallcakes is here to grant the biggest peanut butter wishes. The Scarsdale spot has a daily peanut butter cup cupcake made of chocolate cake, peanut butter cream cheese frosting, and crumbled peanut butter cups to top it off — but the peanut butter goodness doesn’t stop there. The shop has two peanut butter specials; peanut butter cheesecake and peanut butter brownie can be ordered in advance by the dozen.


380 Main St, #1821, Armonk; 914.273.4777

Say hello to this Sugar Hi special, perfect for peanut butter lovers. The Reese’s Peanut Butter cookie is packed with peanut butter, chocolate chips, Reese’s pieces, and a Reese’s peanut butter cup. This special is not available daily but will be available today (for national PB&J Day) and rotates in most weekends.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Sugar Hi (@sugarhiarmonk)

Village Creamery & Sweet Shop

32 Broadway, Valhalla; 914.421.1300

The Village Creamery and Sweet Shop has an array of peanut butter concoctions from ice cream flavors to peanut butter dessert pizzas. Yes, you heard that right. The ice cream pizza features a brownie crust with vanilla ice cream topped with Reese’s pieces and peanut butter drizzle. The all-natural and homemade ice cream flavors are just as exciting. To satisfy your peanut butter cravings, try the cookie monster meets peanut butter cup, peanut butter Nutella swirl, or chocolate brownie peanut butter cup.

Photo courtesy of The Village Creamery & Sweet Shop

140 Grand

140 Grand St, Croton-on-Hudson; 914.271.1127

Tired of playing it safe with the peanut butter and chocolate pairing? Those who really like peanut butter are in luck. Chef Vincenzo De Roco of 140 Grand is cooking up a beloved peanut butter burger featuring a beef patty topped with creamy peanut butter, house-cured pork belly, and onion jam.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Vincenzo De Raco (@chef_vincenzo)

Related: Dig Into Peanut Butter Burgers and Craft Cocktails at Croton’s 140 Grand


Get Westchester's Best Restaurants Guide for FREE! 

Keep a pulse on local food, art, and entertainment content when you join our Westchester newsletter.

No thank you
Top Restaurants