Know Your Bird: A Guide To Buying The Perfect Thanksgiving Turkey

With Halloween just around the corner, ordering a Thanksgiving turkey may seem like the last thing on your mind, but with local producers taking orders (and selling out) in October, now’s the time to order a special bird to crown your Thanksgiving table.

Hemlock Hill Farm

What you get: The Cortlandt Manor farm raises all-natural Broad Breasted White turkeys (the most common Thanksgiving breed). Their birds graze in pastures and are hormone- and preservative-free.

- Advertisement -

Why it’s worth it: “Our turkeys are raised with their health and well-being and our customer’s health and well-being as a top priority. You know where it’s coming from, and you’re supporting your local farmer and community.”

Price/lb: $5.25

How to order: In person at the farm store, by phone, or by email. Visit for contact info.

John Boy’s Farm

What you get: Owner John Ubaldo raises two heritage breeds—White Holland and Bronze. The birds are pasture-raised and chemical-, drug-, and hormone-free.

- Partner Content -

Why it’s worth it: “You are what you eat. These turkeys have been raised out on pasture and fed only non-GMO grains. They’re eating apples in the orchard right now and will be moved to a corn field in November…Not even going to go into the way they raise them for the supermarket.”

Price/lb: $6.25-$7.25

How to order: Orders can be placed by email only at starting November 1. Pickup is at the farm’s store, The Outpost, in Bedford, November 21-22, 24.

Photo by Ben Hider 

Stone Barns Center for Agriculture

- Advertisement -

What you get: Choose from pasture-raised Broad Breasted Whites—which are fed a diet of grass, seeds, and insects—and Heritage breeds. Stone Barns routinely sells out within the first few days (sales open to the general public October 28).

Why it’s worth it: “Whichever bird you choose, you know it’s being raised the way a turkey should be—out on the fresh grass with the health of the animals and the soil at heart of our operation.”

Price/lb: $6.00 for Broad Breasted Whites, $10.00 for Heritage birds.

How to order: Visit and fill out a turkey request form.

Stew Leonard’s

What you get: No preorder required (though it doesn’t hurt). The store offers fresh turkeys from the Shenandoah Valley in Virginia and all-natural, free-range NAKED turkeys, which eat an all-vegetarian diet and are antibiotic- and hormone-free. Across its four locations, the store will sell nearly one million pounds of turkey.

Why it’s worth it: Stew Leonard Jr. serves one of his NAKED turkeys at Thanksgiving: “We like cooking this bird because it has 20 percent more breast meat and 55 percent less fat than regular turkeys!”

Price/lb: Not yet available

How to order: Just show up at the store or call ahead to reserve a bird.  

Our Wine & Food Festival returns June 4-9!

Our Wunderkinds event takes place on May 23!

Our Best of Business Ballot is open through May 15!

Our Healthcare Heroes Awards event takes place on May 9!

Our Westchester Home Builders Awards take place on April 4!

Our Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Forum is March 14!

Unveiled: A Boutique Bridal Brunch is February 25!

Our Best of Westchester Elimination Ballot is open through March 6!

Holiday flash sale ... subscribe and save 50%

Limited time offer. New subscribers only.