Where to Get the Best Ice Cream Cake in Westchester

Photos by Andre Baranowski

We sampled five ice cream cakes, crunchies and all, to find the best that Westchester’s sweet shops have to offer.

Whether you eat it with a fork or spoon (fork is correct, btw), ice cream cake is a slice of heaven. And it is a universally acknowledged truth that an ice cream cake brought to a party instantly elevates the occasion. To do the full depth of our civil service to the citizens of Westchester, we cooled down our test kitchen to taste-test five ice cream cakes from local shops to determine which store (and better yet, which flavor combos) will secure your future invites to shindigs across the county.

The Chic Update at Main Street Sweets

53 Main St, Tarrytown; 914.332.5757

The take on Carvel’s trend brings luscious vanilla ice cream to the forefront of your taste buds. The addition of crunchies and cookie dough sprinkled on top adds a jolt of flavor without being too sweet.

-Staff Favorite-

The Grown-Up Twist at Ice Cream Social

481 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains; 914.358.4323

While whimsical on the outside, this cake means business inside. Salted caramel pretzel tangos with cappuccino Kahlua for a deliciously decadent bite, with added texture from the Oreo crumble.

The Classic at Carvel

287 Halstead Ave, Harrison; 914.835.5081

How could we leave out a birthday party staple that’s also native to Westchester (the first Carvel storefront opened in Hartsdale in 1936.) The classic vanilla/chocolate combo has stood the test of time, but the best part will always be digging the crunchies out.

The Rich & Luxurious at Longford’s Ice Cream

4 Elm Pl, Rye; 914.967.3797

This small-batch ice cream transforms into a cake fit for royalty. Fudgy chocolate chunk and salted caramel Oreo will bring you back for more.

The Purist at Penny Lick Ice Cream

580 Warburton Ave, Hastings-On-Hudson; 914.525.1580

A deviation from the standard two-flavor layered equation, this cookies-and-cream cake has silky whipped topping and a galaxy of cookie chunks. Bonus points for the chocolate-shell drip around the circumference.

Related: The History of Carvel Ice Cream in Westchester County

Cristiana Caruso

Recent Posts

  • Food

Likha Art Cafe Paints a New Picture in Hawthorne

Blending coffee and cultural treats with engaging local art, this new Filipino-owned café — just…

3 hours ago
  • Things To Do

These Are the Best Things to Do in Westchester This Week

We round up the best activities of the week for Westchester residents, including an herb…

8 hours ago
  • Partner Content

Mammograms Still Top Choice for Breast Cancer Screening

With the increased buzz around breast ultrasound as the latest and greatest screening advancement, mammograms…

1 day ago
  • Recipes

7 Fall Recipes for Westchesterites Who Hate Pumpkin Spice

There’s more to autumn flavors than a daily coffee run in Westchester County (especially if…

3 days ago
  • Home & Property

8 Fall Berries to Brighten Your Westchester Garden Into Winter

The arrival of autumn doesn’t mean you have to store the gardening tools. Liven up…

3 days ago
  • Ask The Expert
  • Partner Content
  • Sponsored Content

Jill F. Spielberg, Abrams Fensterman: Ask the Experts

When people get married, they are in love and expect it to last forever. The…

3 days ago