Try These Eggnog-Flavored Treats for the Holidays in Westchester

Adobe Stock/ Atstock Productions

Whether you’re looking for eggnog-flavored ice cream or an eggnog cocktail, here’s where to find the ‘nog throughout Westchester.

As winter approaches in Westchester, it’s time for a new flavor to take over our coffees, ice cream, and baked goods. And what’s better than some good ol’ eggnog-flavored treats? Traditionally, a classic cup of eggnog is made with eggs, milk, heavy crem, and vanilla extract. Now whether you choose to drink it straight up with a dash of cinnamon or enjoy it as an ice cream flavor, the choice is entirely up to you.

Main Street Sweets

35 Main St, Tarrytown; 914.332.5757

This ice cream shop is a local favorite where customers can always expect to see a few specialty and seasonal flavors on the menu. This year, Main Street Sweets scoops maple walnut, pumpkin, cinnamon, and eggnog varieties. Best of all, the ice cream is handmade!


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Main Street Sweets (@msstarrytown)

- Advertisement -

Ice Cream Factory

408 East Sandford Blvd, Mount Vernon; 914.699.1349

The Ice Cream Factory was started by the Guerrino brothers back in 1954. And since then, it’s been offering gourmet Caribbean ice cream flavors to Westchester County. Not only does the Ice Cream Factory have eggnog in stock, but it also has eggnog grapenutt, and eggnog rum raisin flavors, too.

Moderne Barn

430 Bedford Rd, Armonk; 914.730.0001

The next time you head over to Moderne Barn and eat your way through the delicious menu, finish up with the perfect holiday dessert: eggnog cheesecake. This sweet treat has a cinnamon graham cracker crust, cranberry compote, and a topper of vanilla crème fraiche.

- Partner Content -

Company Chophouse & Grill

7 Madison Ave, Larchmont; 914.341.1171

If you’re looking for a spiked eggnog beverage, head over to the Company Chophouse and try its eggnog Old Fashioned. The bartenders shake up Makers Mark, Frangelico, and classic eggnog, then serve it in a cinnamon sugar-rimmed glass. Talk about the perfect seasonal cocktail.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by @companychophouse


Don Coqui

107 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains; 914.576.7676

- Advertisement -

In the heart of White Plains lies the vibrant and energetic Don Coqui, which serves up tradition Puerto Rican food. On the beverage menu, keep an eye out for coquito, the traditional Spanish drink that’s coconut-based and has a dash of rum and spices. The drink, referred to as the Puerto Rican eggnog, is a delicious seasonal selection.

Newbury Gelato 

Just outside of Westchester in Brookfield, CT. lies a family-run gelato shop where everything is made in-house in small batches using all-natural ingredients. They offer around two dozen flavors including their eggnog gelato which is made with eggs, nutmeg, and a touch of holiday magic!


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Newbury Gelato (@newburygelato)

Related: You Need to Try Moderne Barn’s Eggnog Crème Brûlée Recipe