County Pies to Try on National Pie Day

January 23 is National Pie Day, so we thought we’d serve up some succulent slices of the best this county has to offer.

Sour Cherry

Baked by Susan • Croton-on-Hudson

This entry by the 2017 Best of Westchester Best Bakery winner will seduce your taste buds into willing submission. The exquisite classic pie gets a cunning sweet-tart twist from handpicked cherries.

Their secret: They use butter in their crust and fresh, in-season fruit always.

- Advertisement -

Pear and Quince Pie

Martine’s Fine Bake Shoppe • Scarsdale

Unlike any other, Martine’s crystalized-ginger crust explodes with sugar and spice, without detracting from the filling made with uber-juicy Oregon Bartlett pears.

Their secret: Poaching the pear and quince, to bring out the sweet and tangy flavors.

Banana Cream Pie

City Limits • White Plains

With fresh bananas and real cream, this vertiginous trip into tastyland will blindside you into forming a dysfunctional relationship that makes the notorious scene in American Pie seem almost understandable.

- Partner Content -

Their secret: High-fat sweet butter, which produces a crispier, flakier pie crust, enhanced by refrigeration prior to baking. They also vent the pies, for a more evenly cooked result.

Coconut Cream Pie

Bronxville Diner • Bronxville

Go cuckoo for coconuts with this mouthwatering morsel. The first layer of shredded coconut (2” thick) lines the bottom, followed by the dreamy, thick coconut cream, topped with copious shreds of toasted coconut.

Words to the pies: Owner Yiota Koriniotu says their vast variety makes them the “County Kings of Cream Pies!”

Caramel Apple

Kneaded Bread • Port Chester

- Advertisement -

Nothing pairs better than juicy apples and a slather of melted, gooey caramel. What happens when the two unite within the flaky cradle of a pie crust? Pure ecstacy. Yummy Idared apples are cooked down with cinnamon, brown sugar and nutmeg.

Terrific Technique: Caramel is drizzled throughout the pie, creating a flowing river of sticky sweetness in every bite.

For another great slice of life, visit

Our Healthcare Heroes Awards event takes place on May 9!

Our Westchester Home Builders Awards take place on April 4!

Our Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Forum is March 14!

Unveiled: A Boutique Bridal Brunch is February 25!

Our Best of Westchester Elimination Ballot is open through March 6!

Holiday flash sale ... subscribe and save 50%

Limited time offer. New subscribers only.